A Comprehensive Review of Target’s New Affordable Menswear Line, Goodfellow & Co.

A Comprehensive Review of Target’s New Affordable Menswear Line, Goodfellow & Co.

Years ago, Target was a great place to pick up many basic menswear items — items like t-shirts, henleys, polos, even some sweaters. Target’s two in-house brands — Merona and Mossimo — actually did a really great job at making items like those just mentioned that were solid-enough quality, well-priced, and fit well. Then something changed, and for the last few years, the fits and quality of these items has just been off. It was to many people’s great surprise and joy, then, when Target announced just a few months ago that they would be getting rid of Merona and Mossimo and replacing them both with a brand new line of menswear focused on style and fit called Goodfellow & Co. With a lookbook that garnered quite a bit of interest, and the promise of the great Target essentials we all used to know and love — plus, even better, many new fantastic-looking items — this new style move by Target was poised to really be something quite great. Finally, today is the day that the brand is officially available in Target stores around the country as well as online. So, this of course begs the question: Is Target’s new Goodfellow & Co. line of clothing actually any good? Well, I spent my morning at Target to get you the answers to all the questions you might have...

For starters, the new line offers a lot of options. Almost the entire men's section at Target is now Goodfellow & Co. The sizing is pretty sparse, and not everything is available in every size, though. This is either because things are selling out that quickly (not sure this is the reason), or because Target just has not gotten everything in yet (more likely). Either way, it's an issue that should be resolved with some time.

Alright, let's get into it...

I should take this time to note that I am about 6 foot 1, 165 lbs., and usually wear a size small.

THE OKAY

IMG_1793.jpg

Grey BomberJacket

$39.99

It's labeled as a Standard fit and it is. I'm a slim guy and so this thing was too big on me. The material was also rather scratchy and uncomfortable. As far as looks go, though, it's quite nice. And also comes in a green.

IMG_1794.jpg

Green Field Jacket

$39.99

Once again, it's standard fit, and that really shows in the sleeves which are much too big on me here. The waist is mostly fine, but the rounded pattern is a bit strange. Also available in black.

IMG_1808.jpg

Fleece Vest

$24.99

Comes in a bunch of other colors, but no slim fit. Bit too much room in the whole body of this thing.

IMG_1833.jpg

Green Track Jacket 

$29.99

This is actually pretty nice. It's a bit long (something that Target seems to have a real problem with, as we shall see), and the collar is super floppy, but it's not half-bad.

blue ging.jpg

Slim Blue Gingham Dress Shirt

$29.99

Target seems to be offering both dress shirts as well as more casual shirts (the latter with a button-down collar and more color and patterns, as well as more casual fabrics). Both kinds of these shirts come in a Standard and Slim fit option (as well as Big & Tall). As you can see above, the Slim fit shirt actually fits quite nicely, and is a true slim. The sleeves are trim, and the armhole is pretty raised. The body, chest, and waist of the shirt is also nicely slim, and the tail is elongated to help it stay tucked-in all day. As far as a dress shirt goes, it's not bad at all (and even has some stretch to it). However, when you can get, say, Charles Tyrwhitt shirts on sale for the same price, this is a hard purchase to justify as, while the quality is solid, it's not anywhere near as good.

IMG_1804.jpg

Standard Fit Striped Oxford Shirt

$24.99

At a few bucks cheaper than the proper dress shirts, the oxford shirts are slightly more reasonable. Quality is pretty solid, likely comparable to Gap sometimes. The makeup is 100% cotton. The style and color is nice as well. What is confusing is the fit. It's a casual shirt, and a Standard fit, but it fits almost exactly the same way as the Slim dress shirt did. And here is where things really become problematic: I tried on a number of allegedly Standard fit casual shirts and they all fit somewhat differently. 

The flannel fit slimmer than the denim shirt, which was looser than the oxford shirt. There was no rhyme or reason to it, which leads me to conclude it's merely a result of cheaper manufacturing. I really wanted to see what a Slim fit casual shirt would look like, but they had none in the store. Needless to say, while at least some of their shirts are bound to fit you, it's the sort of thing you really need to go in to the store to try and see for yourself. This is not the sort of thing you can order with any reliability online, unfortunately. 

IMG_1846.jpg

Blue T-Shirt

$7.99

The feel of the fabric on this is really quite nice, and has a bit of stretch to it, which is impressive as it's 100% cotton. The fit is a bit tight in the armpit, though, and a touch loose in the bicep for me. At this price, or similar, I prefer Uniqlo tees.

IMG_1854.jpg

Standard Fit Polo

$12.99

The price-point on these things is perfect. The quality of the fabric is good. The collar is thick, as are the buttons. The whole thing feels very substantial. The problem? The fit. Everything about this is weird. The biceps are much too large, and come down too far, and the collar seems too big, even, for the polo. This is only one of their polo offerings, though, and so here is to hoping that the Slim options are better. They had none in the store when I was there, though, so a review of those will have to wait for another time. I sure hope they can replace the excellent Target polos of old, because these certainly don't.

THE GOOD

IMG_1812.jpg

Tweed Blazer

$49.99

Super impressed with this one. It's only partially lined (though it's a heavy fabric and so wears quite heavily), and is 58% cotton, 42% polyester. The waist, nor the sleeves would require any alteration for me. For a blazer to fit this well in the sleeves off-the-rack is no small feat. I'm wearing a size small, and while it's billed as a Standard fit, it fits quite slim. In the sleeves, at least, this jacket is much slimmer than Uniqlo's, which are comparably designed and priced. In fact, just like Uniqlo, these jackets are rather cropped at the bottom, and appear quite short. If it weren't for that, I might have walked out with one of these today, but, as a tall guy, shorter blazers just look ridiculous on me. (Sizing up, by the way, is just all around a bad idea here. It's trash bag city.)

IMG_1841.jpg

Navy Blazer

$39.99

A truly classic piece, and an essential in any man's wardrobe, and Target executed well here. It's all exactly the same story as with the tweed blazer above, but this one is 97% cotton and 3% spandex.

IMG_1825.jpg

Shawl Collar Cardigan

$34.99

The fit on this is pretty good — not too long, nor too short, a common problem for sweaters like this. The sleeves are a bit tight, which often causes strange bunching by the elbows on thicker knits like this sweater. It feels pretty soft, and will probably last a decent amount of time. I still think it's a bit overpriced, though, when you can get much higher quality from, say, Banana Republic or J Crew during a good sale.

IMG_1851.jpg

Brown V-Neck Sweater

$24.99

These are really actually quite nice. The fit is just about perfect, and fits extremely similarly to how a Banana Republic Standard fit sweater would fit. It could stand to come in a bit at the sides, but it's really pretty solid overall. The sleeves fit perfectly, I would say. The makeup is 80% cotton, 15% nylon, and 5% wool. Not amazing, not terrible for the price.

IMG_1858.jpg

Slim Fit Chinos

$22.99

The price on these is pretty good for what you are getting. They feel a bit stiff, but they also feel like they will really hold up over time. These are not cheap-feeling pants by any means. The fit is pretty great as well. While I like my pants a bit slimmer (see below), for those that like a Slim fit, these are gonna be a great basic option for you. There is a bit of stretch to them as well. They run a bit long, but nothing that a tailor cannot fix. (Target is also offering a whole bunch of other fits, like Athletic and so on, so there is a really, really good chance anyone will be able to find a pair here that will fit him well. Target did a really great job on this.)

IMG_1859.jpg

Skinny Fit Chinos

$22.99-$25.99

While this skinny fit tapers more on the bottom like I wanted, the thighs are practically glued on at this point. If you like the J Crew 484 fit like I do (which seems to sit right between Target's Skinny and Slim), Target is not going to be where you will get your chinos. Even with the nice amount of stretch to these, they are just not my chino. That being said, they feel very nice, and they are a true skinny fit, and the price is right. There's nothing inherently wrong with them — they just don't quite fit me.

IMG_1844.jpg

Denim

$27.99-$39.99

Target had no jeans in my size when I was there, so I was not able to try them on. However, they are offered in all the same fits as the chinos (not all jeans come in all fits, but there are still numerous fits in their denim). The selvedge denim looks nice, as you can see above, and the flex denim felt really good (I tried on a pair a few sizes too big), though is not made up of the best material. For the cheaper pairs of denim here, if they fit, they are surely worth it. For the selvedge, you'd probably do better elsewhere for a few dollars more.

THE BAD

IMG_1796.jpg

Shoes

$44.99

Stay away from the shoes, big time. They don't resemble leather in any way, and even the treads on the bottom of the above pair of boots, for instance, feel and look terrible. If a truly quality pair of shoes at this price point sounds too good to be true, that's because it is. What you can do for regular clothing like shirts, sweaters, and tees, cannot be done quite the same way for shoes. It's as simple as that. 

IMG_1828.jpg

Bomber Jackets

$39.99

These jackets fit terribly. They are too short in the sleeves and body, and incredibly baggy in the sleeves and back as well. Skip 'em.

IMG_1847.jpg

Long Sleeve Knit Crew

$14.99

These look and feel so good it is such a pity that they are so comically and absurdly long. What the heck happened here, Target?

Henley

$14.99

The fit of these henleys is just all around odd. It's far too tight across the chest, and then too loose in the waist. And... they're too long. They were hard to get on and off, even. These are nothing like the old henleys that used to be so great at Target. They're thicker, and nicer quality, sure, but they fit horribly.

IMG_1856.jpg

Rugby Shirt

$16.99

Once again, I have no idea what the heck happened with these. They look and feel good, but the fit is just horrendous. These things are skin-tight. Unwearable. I would have bought multiple colors of this item if they had fit. But they don't. So, pass.

THE SURPRISINGLY EXCELLENT

IMG_1863.jpg

Knit Pant

$24.99

These pants were a total surprise. I saw them on the rack and did not know what to expect. What they are, though, are some incredibly fitting and feeling pants. These things look just like dress pants, but feel better than any sweatpants you've worn. To heck with those $150 Lu Lu Lemon pants people seem to be into these days, these things are fantastic. They come in black, also, and I might just have to get myself a pair — especially at the ridiculous price (which is likely possible due to their makeup). They do run a bit long, but, again, nothing a tailor can't fix. 

CONCLUSION

The Goodfellow & Co. line offers a whole array of other products, too, like socks (which come in multiple sizes!, though are made up of no cotton nor wool), hats, boxers, as well as zip-up and pullover hoodies. They also seem to have some great-looking sweatpants and even pajama pants that I did not have a chance to give a test run. Needless to say, there is a lot here, and it's more than worth your time to stop by your local Target to take a look. In all honesty, it'll be pretty hard to shop these items online, but if you head out to a physical store, I'd be surprised if you left empty-handed.

So, of all the items above, what did I actually walk away with purchasing today? Just those knit pants, in the end. Everything else, for one reason or another, was just not for me. The real bummer here is that just about any item that was “Okay” or “Bad” only fell into those categories due to the fit. The quality, styling, and details were all just fine, if not more than fine. If Target can iron out some of the clear fit problems they are having, just about everything reviewed here would move into the “Good” category, and I would have bought a whole lot more. (While, certainly, their line of clothing cannot accommodate all body-types, it needs to at least be consistent with itself — some shirts cannot be super tight while others are baggy.) Thus, with the affordable-but-by-no-means-cheap pricing, as it stands now, many of these items are just not so worth it.

But some positivity here, because Target really did do a great job here: Overall, quality and fit have improved drastically from what we have come to expect from Target over the last few years. With the launch of Goodfellow & Co., Target has just become a real player in the menswear space. There is still work to be done on Target's part — and I hope they continue to improve — but this is a major step in the right direction, and a real foundation upon which to build. And there are surely many deals to be had, though what, exactly, you'll end up buying will depend on your luck as to what happens to fit your body type. But something will work out. There's enough good here for me to say that with confidence.

 

We want to hear your thoughts! Connect with us on Twitter, Facebook, or Email...
In Search of the Best Men's Monthly Subscription Box: A Review of Gentleman's Box (August 2017)

In Search of the Best Men's Monthly Subscription Box: A Review of Gentleman's Box (August 2017)